Choosing between Hermitage Bay vs Hammock Cove? Read the feel, rooms, and pacing fast. Two beloved boutique luxuries on the same island, both perfect for two, yet the experiences feel different.
The setting and feel
Hermitage Bay unfolds along a crescent of soft sand with hillside cottages climbing into green. The soundtrack is birds and water, the palette is natural wood and cream, and the mood is quietly indulgent.
Hammock Cove sits right on the water with villa decks over the sea, plunge pools that catch the light, and a slightly more social, design-forward energy. Both are intimate. One leans cocoon. One leans contemporary.
The rooms and privacy
Hermitage’s hillside cottages deliver wraparound views and separation from the beach scene. If you crave privacy, this is a strong play. Hammock Cove’s villas keep you near the water with plunge pools and personal ambassadors; mornings are luminous, evenings are moody and photogenic. Privacy is excellent at both, just expressed differently.
Dining and pacing
Hermitage’s dining feels garden-to-table with an unhurried cadence; perfect after a day that drifted by the water. Hammock Cove layers in creative plates, strong cocktails, and the kind of service that remembers your preferences by night two. Either way, I hold one dinner off-property with a view if you like a sense of place beyond the resort.
Which fits you
Choose Hermitage Bay if you want hillside romance, bare-footed elegance, and the sense that time stretches. Choose Hammock Cove if you want water at your feet, design-forward villas, and a personal-ambassador rhythm.
Tell me which detail matters most—views from above or water at your feet—and I will match you to the property and villa that fits.
